You may have heard about a Winnipeg restaurant that has decided not to allow children under the age of 15. As expected, the decision prompted considerable backlash, including from people who may never visit the restaurant or even live in the area.
The restaurant is designed to offer a quiet, intimate dining experience. For many people, dining there would likely be a luxury, perhaps something reserved for a special occasion. Those choosing to spend their money on that experience have certain expectations. Some may have arranged childcare specifically so they could enjoy a few hours away from the responsibilities of parenting and simply spend time as adults.
I am not sure there is anything unreasonable about that.
Actually, for many children, sitting quietly through several courses in an intimate dining atmosphere would hardly be an enjoyable evening. I am positive my own children would have found it more of a punishment then an enjoyable experience. This is not the only option for a restaurant in the area. There are numerous restaurants and dining options, including takeout if you really wanted the food this specific restaurant offers. Different experiences serve different purposes.
Which makes me ask why the backlash?
I raised two wonderful children, and there are no words to adequately describe how much I love them. They are an enormous part of my life. However, there were certainly times when I needed a little break from them. I suspect there were occasions when they could have benefited from a break from me as well.
If I wanted a break from my own children, whom I love so much, it is pretty safe to say, I wasn’t looking to entertain anyone else’s children.
I often think back to playing cards at my friend Henrietta’s house. It was a busy, sometimes hectic household, but one of those places where everyone immediately felt welcome. It was rare not to find a dozen people of all ages gathered in that little Heights home.
Henrietta had one rule: no children in the kitchen while adults were playing cards and visiting.
The adults could relax, have conversations, laugh, joke and sometimes share the more difficult moments of life. The children were safe and nearby, but they were not required to be the centre of attention every moment. Nobody was disadvantaged by this. In fact, everyone benefited.
There are activities and events designed for every age group. I don’t feel excluded when I am not invited to participate in a children’s activity or offered the treats at an event specifically created for younger people. I understand that the event simply isn’t about me, even if I truly love a bouncy castle.
Weddings, graduations, formal dinners and other special occasions also come with different expectations. Some events require quiet, attention or a certain atmosphere. Not every experience is appropriate for every age, and at some point, we all have to learn, not everything is about us.
Of course, inclusion remains incredibly important. When planning events, particularly those involving children, every effort should be made to accommodate children of all abilities and disabilities. Accessibility and meaningful participation matter, and while we have made progress, there is still work to be done.
However, inclusion does not mean every event must accommodate every age group.
Parents who believe their children are perfectly behaved at all times and in every setting, may find age restrictions difficult to accept. But we must also recognize that not every child has the same temperament, and not every occasion is appropriate for young audiences. Nor can exceptions reasonably be made for some children while excluding others.
Rules are often established because previous experiences have demonstrated why they are necessary.
Sometimes, allowing children to enjoy their own age-appropriate activities while adults enjoy theirs is not exclusion. It is simply recognizing that different ages have different needs, and that there is value in making room for both.
